Shoshone County Cancels Assessor Recount After Filing Defect
A planned recount in the Shoshone County assessor’s election was canceled after Republican candidate Robert Savage’s application was found incomplete, leaving Democrat Katie Murray’s 17-vote lead unchanged for now.
Shoshone County Clerk Lori Osterberg announced the cancellation Wednesday. The recount had been set for Friday morning in Shoshone County District Court after Savage submitted his request Nov. 13.
Recount application requirements
Osterberg said the Idaho Attorney General’s Office advised the clerk that the filing did not contain every required element. “The Office of the Idaho Attorney General has advised the Shoshone County Clerk that not all required elements of the recount application were received,” Osterberg said.
Under Idaho Code 34-2302, a recount request must specify the precinct or precincts to be reviewed. Candidates also must pay $100 for each precinct included in the request.
Shoshone County completed its election canvass Nov. 10, and Idaho law gives candidates 20 days after canvassing to seek a recount. Savage said he intends to pursue another recount, though it was not known Thursday whether he had formally filed a revised application.
Election results
Murray received 2,296 votes in the Nov. 3 general election, while Savage received 2,279. Murray won eight of the county’s 14 precincts, and Savage won six.
Murray’s margin in Kellogg was three votes. The listed precincts included Pinehurst, Kingston, Osburn, Wallace and Kellogg.
Ballot concerns
Savage said he had concerns that some voters may have shaded party-designation areas on ballots rather than the voting ovals. At least 10 ballots at one Shoshone County polling place were reportedly marked that way.
He said he was not accusing election officials of wrongdoing and said he would accept the result if a recount produces the same outcome. “If a recount confirms the original results, I will respect them,” Savage said.
When a recount proceeds, election officials handle the ballots in the precincts named in the petition. The ballots are kept secure, examined publicly and tabulated again, while candidates or their representatives may observe.